Old Town Pizza Co

Reviews

• Daniella C.

  star star star star star_border 10 June 2026

  I ordered from foodsby which is a similar food app like Grubhub and door dash but for my office building. I had the slice previously and it was so good I decided to stop in and grab a quick bite.
  
  It is a more walk-in store front. There is a few tables with two chairs on each, inside and outside. A little area for condiments. Personally, the pizza is delicious to me and I have only tried slices. It is also fairly priced. They have two options with the slice of pizza to ether get a slice & your choice of canned drink for $5.25 or a slice & your choice of a liter for $6. I recommend to order the liter! I know it may seem like a lot or you won't finish it all, but the slices are thick and  especially the crust so 1 can doesn't really help. It would be nice if they had a soda machine for those that dine in, but maybe that's why there is the option for the liter and I recommend it! The sausage they use is tasty! I am picky with my sausage pizza so I was surprised I liked it so much! I recommend if you try a slice to go during lunch or dinner hours for a fresh slice. The menu has a variety of options and they offer catering.

• Matt D.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 20 May 2026

  Old Town Pizza Co and if you get a slice from them that's what you get an old and cold slice. "Old town quality. Old town tradition" I'm glad we live in the present because we can actually find a good slice or pizza.

• Barry F.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 19 May 2026

  We ordered a catering order for 20 people last Sunday. The ordering process felt like I was interrupting their day. Getting a total was a chore and the guy on the phone wasn't exactly Mr. Personable. The order came on time and it was completely wrong. They had combined our order with another order and tried to deliver all of the food to us.
  We did our best to help a confused driver get our order correct. When all was said and done we got most of our order. It was a catering order and yet they added almost $19.00 for plastic plates and silverware.
  So we called the owner Scott. He was unsympathetic and refused to give a credit for the plastic-ware that should have been included. He was not much nicer than the first guy, which makes sense that an employees attitude would reflect the owners himself.  
  Between the order being messed up, the annoying ordering process, the food being at best mediocre, the extra charge for something that should have been included, and the owners attitude we will never order here again. I would strongly urge you to try one of the many other fine establishments in the area and avoid these guys. They simply do not care and it shows. Sad really.

• Ryan L.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 17 May 2026

  Do yourself a favor for a slice of pizza and keep going down Roosevelt to Aurelios. The flavor was terribly lacking, they did not heat my slice and it was lukewarm at best. Aurelios is 3x the taste, and served hot.

• Lincoln G.

  star star star star star 16 May 2026

  Very filling pizza, well worth the price, could have been a little less sloppy but I personally enjoy messy food lol.